Thanks for the update, @Eric. To answer your question:
Given the difficulties with chat currently, I think all messages to everyone is the way to go right now.
It is a good default, and should always remain available as an option for event organizers if it’s possible to do the selection on a per-event basis.
From that base, it may be worth it to re-examine whether limiting chat reach can be implemented in a way that doesn’t cause issues, especially for racing.
And yes, as detailed by others above, bugs remain in the current implementation. There’s still:
- Yellow/Red not visible to all (or each other)
- All messages not visible to Yellow/Red
- All messages within a bunch of riders not visible to everyone
- Other event chats bleeding into chat (especially run events, especially Watopia Pier…)