I have a new TACX Neo 2T. When doing Zwift workouts with the ERG mode selected I have significant power swings (+/- 15% of selected value). These swings are not due to changes in cadence - I maintain a reasonably steady cadence. The trainer takes several seconds to attempt to return to the selected power, but generally overshoots the mark, resulting in wide swings and inconsistent loading, which is not really the desired result of ERG mode training.
However, when I do ERG workouts using the TACX utility app, power requirements are fairly smooth and close to the selected power value. The problem is that using the app gives you nothing but the graph on the app screen to watch, which defeats the purpose of a high dollar interactive trainer.
Anyone out there have similar problems with the TACX ERG mode? I generally like the TACX trainer, but will probable return it if this problem cannot be resolved. Thanks -
Haven’t encountered this during my ERG workouts with the 2T. Though what I do with power changes in workouts is i gradually ramp it up to not stress the trainer and not just stamp the power at once to reach the required power output. By the way how many watts are you doing?
I generally am in the 200-300 watt range, but I have encountered the problem all the way from 130 to 300 watts. I can reach reasonably stable outputs only if I am very careful about the cadence. Since the ERG function is supposed to produce the selected resistance no matter the cadence this is not acceptable. Once of the most interesting parts of this is that the ERG function in very smooth and dependable when I am using the TACX Training app to control the workout, but not when I am using Zwift.
I read from a tacx forums that a slippage will probably happen during a watts surge due to the Neo not having a physical belt but the magnets need a short time to adjust. A smoother pedal stroke minimizes this.
Make sure nothing else is controlling the trainer. Disconnect everything than reconnect only Zwift. If something else is connected to the trainer it will affect erg.
I’ve not had a problem with my 2t in zwift. Hopefully get it sorted.
I had a similar issue whilst using the TACX app. It turned out I needed to increase the Power % graph at the bottom of the TACX workout or under settings. There may be something similar under Zwift. Very frustrating I know.
I have a “problem” doing 600w+ intervals with neo 2t in ERG mode. It is impossible to maintain smooth cadence. Every pedal stroke is divided into 2 separate parts and not one smooth round. I did not have this problem on Elite Suito. Is it a trainer error or that is some sort of normal because magnetic brakes?
I have this problem too. The trained builds an intense amount of resistance if I’m underpowered and takes off resistance if I’m overpowered. I have a 2T, so it didn’t solve the problem being discussed here. I genuinely think the app is designed to work with cadence, so when the cadence is low, it ramps up resistance to achieve the watts in the workout, vice versa. I don’t think anything is wrong with the trainer, it’s just so fast and accurate that it can sting if you’re cadence is inconsistent or your fatigued. The guy that wrote he does not have problems hinted at this when he mentioned building up the cadence to select a smooth cadence. Problem is, I’m a low cadence power down sort of rider, so these work out modes can be tough. Many are geared for cardio, so they are after a quick and consistent cadence. That’s my two cents, I’ll just stick with pace partners.
Here we go in 2023 - I have exactly this same issue. Tacx Neo simply does not work well with Zwift workouts. Regular free riding is fine but with the resistance changes in workouts it cannot sustain the set resistance, either overshooting the target or not applying enough resistance that I can reach the target. Tried ant+ and Blue tooth, Zwift and tacx app resistance set to 100% but no luck!
I’m now having to returning this to Garmin and will go back to a Wahoo kickr
Hi, I’ve been having the same exact issue with my Kickr Core but, specifically, when I use companion to pair. it doesn’t seem to be a problem of a specific trainer but Zwift’s…
I did have some problems as well in a free ride that eventually solved by its own.
I’ve written support team and I am working with them, but I believe it will take a long time to get solved.
Cheers for the reply mate. I have a V4 kickr too which my wife uses. I tried that today and it’s working spot on. Waiting to get the tacx refunded now then I’m just pulling the trigger on a v6 kickr.
I have not used thr kickr core though so not sure there. Good luck I hope they resolve it for you soon.
I used a Neo TACX for several months and really liked the unit for free riding but could not get it to work properly with Zwift in the ERG mode – the resistance would vary ± 25%.
I eventually purchased a Wahoo Kickr bike and find that it very accurate in the ERG mode, including Zwift Workout rides. Also have found that having a unit with dependable resistance allows me to create better training rides, including rides that duplicate the resistance in some of my real world rides.
I hope they resolve it for you soon.