Official Strava Segments with Markers

(Mick Neal Intent (C)) #1

Can we please get some official Zwift created Strava segments that also have in-game markers? It would be nice to have some segments to use as goals that are actually accurate and marked on course.

(Daren Chandisingh 🌱 [Vision]) #2

I’m not keen on Zwift integrating too much with Strava. Zwift is an independent product and should remain so. They don’t have the “Strava Premium” tie up any more either. Uploading to third party products is one thing, but building features around them? No thanks.

TBH I’d much rather see Zwift building these sorts of things into their own platform. They already have it to an extent. For example, the KOM and “sprints”. They’re marked and timed. All they really need to do (besides add more of them) is to create more durable league tables that can be accessed online or through the game. They have the tables already, but they’re ephemeral.

(Mick Neal Intent (C)) #3

Zwift does not have enough existing “official” segments and depending on who creates the Strava segment to match it they usually miss the start or end by a bit, sometimes intentionally. Zwift has partnered with plenty of companies, this seems like a pretty basic ask.

(Daren Chandisingh 🌱 [Vision]) #4

If you stick to the “ZwiftInsider verified” segments you won’t got far wrong. No reason to pull Strava-specific stuff into Zwift.

(Paul Allen (Watopia Wayfinder)) #5

Zwift has NO official Strava segments, there are however Zwiftinsider Verified Strava segments within Zwift.

(Mick Neal Intent (C)) #6

The ZwiftInsider segments are lacking. There are lots of sections I use to do intervals, it be nice to have accurate segments for those AND on course marking of them.

(Daren Chandisingh 🌱 [Vision]) #7

You don’t get markings in the real world for Strava segments, so I don’t see why you need them in Zwift.

If you don’t like the Strava segments other people have created, go ahead and create your own. Mark them as private and they won’t pollute the general space.

(Mick Neal Intent (C)) #8

Plenty of the local IRL segments around me are either marked (someone actually put up signs) or clearly de-lineated. Zwift is a game, gamify it!

(Daren Chandisingh 🌱 [Vision]) #9

I absolutely agree with gamifying Zwift. What I disagree with is pulling Strava-specific stuff into it.

(i van) #10

Aren’t the KOM’s already marked in Zwift? The sprints have a green marker on the right side of the road with a green strip on the road, red for climbs, etc…

(Jim Mattson) #11

The only problem with the ZwiftInsider Verified segments is that they often don’t match up with the actual in-game segments. At least, my Strava-reported times for ZwiftInsider Verified segments often don’t match up with my in-game times for the same segments.

As for dumping Strava and putting all of this information in a Zwift product…I’m all for that! When can I see things like “analyze segment” and rankings for my age group, weight class, followers, etc. for Zwift KOMs and sprints in, say, ZCA? Bring it!

I’m thinking of this today, because I’d really like to see a history of all of my Bambino Fondos. Alas, I can’t find an appropriate segment on Strava (I don’t know where the finish line is, so I can’t make my own), and the Zwift replacement for Strava analytics is still vaporware.

(Paul Allen (Watopia Wayfinder)) #12

I just said there are only ZwiftInsider segments and no official Zwift segments. I am not saying they are accurate or anything else.

(Pitch Blank) #13

combining zwift routes with strava maps/gps/OSM xyz was the biggest marketing nonsense. my browser keeps beeing slower and slower. the segments spam just doesnt come to an end… sorry but its is really annoying. and in the end for what? who has the biggest stem?:scream:

(Daren Chandisingh 🌱 [Vision]) #14

Along with Paul’s comment, the other aspect of this is the way Strava segment creation works. You simply can’t make segments start and end at precise points. For example, these are the two choices I have for starting a segment at the base of a particular climb in New York:

OK, maybe it’s not huge, but the limitation is there.

I’m sure Eric S. has got the segments as precise as possible within the limitations of GPS “tracking” in Zwift and Strava segment creation.

(Jim Mattson) #15

All the more reason for Zwift to provide their own analytics!

(Daren Chandisingh 🌱 [Vision]) #16

I don’t disagree! In fact, I’ve said pretty much the same thing myself.

I don’t give a stuff about Strava segments within Zwift, I’d far prefer Zwift to maintain their own in-game leaderboards. (And a load of other stuff that Strava does, particularly stuff it only does if you’re a paying “Summit” member.)