Getting the most out of a 'dumb' trainer

Hi All, I’m new to zwift and have a dumb trainer (Tacx Booster) it’s set up to the resistance level that zwift suggests for the power curve of my trainer. Also have Garmin HR strap, speed and cadence sensors- all pair fine. Workouts and FTP have been good during this 7day trial but would be interested to know if others with similar trainers stay on the resistance level and go up and down their bike gears when gradients start or up and down the trainers resistance levels? Just trying to get the most out of the manual trainer and how others use them. Also can you still race but in Cat D? I don’t have a power meter to compare my stats against. Will be continuing with zwift as online support desk has been great with my setup questions. Many thanks

Hello Marie. I’m pretty new to Zwift myself - about two weeks worth. I’m also on a dumb trainer, as I didn’t want to invest too much before I knew if I’d like it.

I love it.

I manually shift gears to simulate slopes.Now, I’ve never been a biker outside of Zwift, so take everything I say with a grain of salt. In addition, I take it from others that are actual cyclists that hills probably shouldn’t be harder. After all, watts are watts - you just put the bike into a gear that allows you to keep pumping out your watt maximum. You go slower, but it’s not necessarily physically more taxing. (Again, that’s just what I’ve heard.)

BUT… as a novice, that doesn’t feel right to me. I like the fact that hills give me a chance to really push myself hard. So completely reverse of what you’d do in the real world, go to a higher gear on inclines while trying to keep the highest cadence I can tolerate. The higher gear simulates the harder incline.

I have four gears I use (4,5,6,7 on my “dial.”)

I use 5 as my default level. It’s what I use if the incline is anywhere from -2% to +2%.
I use 6 as my middle climb. It’s for 3% or 4%.
I use 7 as my hard climb. It’s for 5%+
I use 4 as my downhill gear - for -3% or lower.

I thought I’d find it unrealistic or strange or cumbersome, but I actually like it a lot. It feels pretty real and immersive to me. I don’t plan to change anytime soon. In fact, if I ever get a smart trainer, I hope I can get it to work in a similar way.

1 Like

You actually should not be changing the resistance level/lever on your trainer, there is only a power curve for the one that Zwift suggest you put in on in the Pairing Screen.

3 Likes

Glad you are enjoying Zwift. For racing, keep it in the right level but remember without a power meter, your power will usually be higher than reality so most race organizers have banned zwift power estimated power from winning or even podium positions.

If you change levels, it should be for training purposes and should be in the harder levels which may simulate uphills better. But only training, not racing.

If or when you get addicted to racing, you will want a power meter. A power wheel or other used power meter can sometimes be reasonably priced. I got a 1200 power wheel on ebay for only 100 dollars. I still have a ‘dumb’ trainer but I love it (smooth and quiet).

2 Likes

It sounds like you’re trying to make a “dumb” trainer emulate a “smart” trainer by changing your resistance settings but that really won’t work. Just set your trainer to the resistance level recommended by Zwift and ride it the way it is that way Zwift can do a reasonably good job of calculating your power. Make sure you check your tire pressure and mounting as these can effect power numbers and lastly do a spin down calibration and you should be all set.

When riding with a dumb trainer keep an eye on your watts and speed and when a hill comes just try to maintain watts and/or speed. Don’t mess around with the resistance.

Yes, you can race without a power meter or smart trainer but your results on Zwiftpower may be not allowed in some events if you do really well but go ahead and race and see where you end up. I would recommend registering with Zwiftpower.com as it keeps a nice record of all your races and racing efforts.

2 Likes

Many thanks everyone for your replies, I’ve learned something new from them all. I really appreciate this help as these things can be a minefield when you don’t know what your doing. It’s a great workout neither way! Thanks again :+1: