I’m not good on the technical side of things, so I’m going to let Paul or someone else advise you there. In the meantime, the absolute best suggestion I have is to do your workouts in Resistance mode.
It adds to the mental load in its own way, of course, but at least you’ll be able to hit your power targets properly and avoid the frustration of the wattage flying all over the place, at least until a fix is found for your Erg issue.
Paul has given his usual excellent advice on this.
I’ll just chip in to say that it sounds like two separate (but probably related) things have changed here. Firstly, as has been said, you definitely had some sort of power smoothing going on in ERG mode previously, which you don’t have any longer. Secondly, you now seem to have more wild fluctuations going on than before when in ERG mode.
At this point I’d be testing it with something else, some other app, or a cycling computer, or a Garmin watch, and see if it can run an ERG mode workout as expected.
Nice quiz, certainly too hard for me to tell.
Was today’s workout in Resistance mode and has there been a very recent Zwift change to now make it easier to spot the difference?
FWIW, I’m having the exact same problems. I went from my roadbike on a Kickr Core 1 to the zwift bike on a kickr core 2 at the end of March. My output dropped by 10-30 watts. I thought I’d try a ramp test to see if I was as far off as it felt. The new app doesn’t have the ERG mode indication on the workout selection as it used to. Its in the app on the pop up ribbon menu at the bottom. I put the setup in ERG mode. Typically in ERG mode I found I’d maintain the watts regardless of my cadence. Now I’m bouncing all over and have to really focus to hit the watts target. I don’t detect any ERG function while riding.