tried the new video ride feature today! it was fun, but wanted to write out all my feedback here.
i rode the colorado river sunrise and the sa calobra routes.
colorado river:
this was fun, but maybe a little boring. i saw a youtube video about zwift route design, and in that video the designer mentioned having things to visually fixate on to keep the ride interesting. this ride didn’t have too much of that. it was gorgeous scenery, but it too easily fell into the background. EDIT: here’s the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HBbQTnAOt4M
there were some “overlay” problems. one of the KOM starts was around a bend, and i could see the red parts peeking through the bend at me. there was also a black SUV going the other way with around 14km left to ride that rendered “behind” some riders that were up the road from me. from my viewpoint, they should have been obscured by the oncoming vehicle.
having the other riders there made a big difference. if these routes will be empty, they will be less fun.
i found it difficult to judge where the draft was with the new camera angle
i did many ride-on bombs. the visuals aren’t up to par yet – you can’t see the “radius” of the bomb like in a virtual world, and the other riders don’t get a temporary “highlight” either. the thumbs do drop, but that’s it. i also thought it was difficult to tell when the bomb would hit the other riders. something about the perspective is just disorienting.
the middle of the route KOM got up to 11%, but you could hardly tell from the visuals.
sa calobra:
i’m a huge climb portal fan, but this was other-level stuff. SO MUCH better than riding the same route in the portal. i didn’t feel as tortured by my wattage as i went up
i’ve ridden sa calobra IRL, and so that might bias me, but i loved the scenery and how realistic everything was
being on a constant climb made the lack of perception of the grade way less problematic
some of the sharp turns left you with a strange angle to be viewing the road. zwift does a good job of re-positioning the rider on the road to make up for it, but it’s odd
it feels like a HUGE miss not to be able to look out at the views with the camera angle controls on this route. i wanted to turn my head left so badly in so many places
i really want to U turn this one when i get to the top. half the fun of the climb portal is coasting back down after you toasted yourself on the way up
i had no idea when i cross the intermediate check points – they need better visuals
will i want to pay extra for this? not sure yet. if all the climb portal rides were turned into this, that would be quite a value prop from my perspective. i’m testing the coach out, too, but it’s way too early to say anything about that yet.
anyway, i really appreciate the free preview, it’s fantastic to give this a shot and weigh it out. thanks, zwift!
The 11% section on Colorado River is the detail I’d follow up on. Being able to read the gradient number and being able to read the road are different things.
Your Sa Calobra comparison is useful here. You already know you’re climbing there, so the picture doesn’t have to communicate every change in effort. A rolling route asks more of it.
I’d start by making the next gradient change clearer on the existing elevation profile. For reporting this particular section, a short clip starting 15 seconds before it, with the gradient display visible, would help separate a missing visual cue from a timing mismatch.
When you reached that 11% section, did the trainer resistance tell you the road had steepened before the picture did?
good clarification. the trainer worked properly, it increased resistance as expected. the road just “visually” still looked pretty flat – or at least not 11%.
i did the glen canyon route and it was similar.
i also did a workout on a video route – the arches that delineate the change between segments of the workout are visually missing (you CAN see them on the mini-map), and that took some getting used to. definitely hope they can add those back in eventually.
That’s been my view also with these routes.. When the gradient kicks up, visually things still look “flat”. Not what I would expect when riding a climb outside.
Sometimes that happens in real life too, especially with straight sections of road, I can think of sections on Col de la Madeleine like that. It looks moderately uphill but is steeper than it appears.
The someone looks at their Garmin and that’s the reality check for what the gradient actually is.
I am really liking the video routes. A lot of that is just the added variety. There are parts of Watopia that I would be happy to never ride again, e.g. the desert. They need to at least triple or quadruple the number of routes. I would like a large selection of 25 to 45 minute choices. Unfortunately, the general consensus seems to be it is not worth the extra charge, so I expect this to fail.
Presumably the camera is always pointing at the same angle relative to the road, so gradient and gradient changes have no visual cues. I would think they could automatically adjust the camera tilt “in post” according to the estimated gradient. This might need to be exaggerated to give the right effect.
The other thing that would really help the visuals would be photo-realistic rider avatars rather than cartoon style …
These are minor criticisms. In general, I think the videos are superb and a great addition to the product.
One of the things that make it more jarring is how exaggerated things are in Zwift’s virtual world. You switch to something more realistic and it looks so tame in comparison.
I was thinking of this the other day whlie riding on of the video routes. Zwift’s exaggeration means not only visual cues for slopes but often more changes in resistance. Both of which increase the immersion. By comparison routes based on actual roads will often have long erstretches with barely any changes, so they will naturally be less immersive.
Workout arches are completely missing, so besides the audible countdown sound, no visual indication of where the arch
I think Zwift should remove the videoed cars/trucks etc that are on the road and read this with generated ones. This would allow a car etc to keep passing you when stopped and also maintain it’s speedy: when you on a climb, the car etc coming towards you matches your climb speed ie: video speed, so if your climbing at 7km/h, the car is coming towards you at that speed
The arches do appear in the minimap. Not perfect, but at least there’s something. I’m hoping the normal arches will be added at some point, though.
And without the the arches, at least for me, the 1 second discrepancy between the interval timer and the ride timer seems exaggerated, as compared to when the arches exist. Just a mental thing, I know, but I’m hoping that someday this discrepancy will be corrected.
Sharing my thoughts about Zwift Plus Video and Coach features.
The real world video and bike integration is great in general. However, I need the group rides and robo-pacer rides to push me in my training/fitness and for enjoyment. While it is cool to see different places around the world for rides, much of it is monotonous. I had this problem with Rouvy as well. I prefer the graphically generated rides on Zwift since they provide constant visual interest and a nice variety of rolling hills, inclines, and climbs.
Two suggestions: I have enjoyed commercial treadmills that have running video routes (speed controlled for my pace) with world-wide live participants, similar to Zwift, but the runs are edited to only show interesting video - no monotonous stretches. It is a tradeoff vs real-world rides, but one that I would find more interesting.
One REQUEST: The best feature of R-o-u-v-y that I really miss is the three virtual riders that surround me every ride. They tend to pass me and push me until I can’t keep pace, and then adjust to keep me motivated to keep up with them. This is a fantastic feature that I would upgrade my Zwift account to get :-).
I tried the Zwift Coach for the week of free Zwift Plus access as well, but it was not inspiring. It is fine to set my goals, but there is no interactive pushing or progress toward goals during rides. When I finish a ride it is not motivating to see ‘your target was 1.5 hrs but you only rode 1.25 hrs’, and something to the effect of ‘your effort was less than what this ride should have been’ - that would have been helpful during the ride, not as a summary.
For now I would not consider upgrading my account as I would only chose standard Zwift group and robo-pacer rides and I enjoy the thoughtful visual stimulation Zwift puts into its virtual worlds.